Koran Revealed in Israel?

How can one present the case that the Muslim holy book was revealed not in Mecca/Medina but rather it was revealed in Israel near Sodom and Gomorrah. I have come to this conclusion not based on wishful thinking rather the evidence is found in the Koran.

Lets read Surah Saffat (37) Ayat 137-8

  • Sahih International: And indeed, you pass by them in the morning – And at night. Then will you not use reason?
  • Pickthall: And lo! ye verily pass by (the ruin of) them in the morning – And at night-time; have ye then no sense?
  • Yusuf Ali: Verily, ye pass by their (sites), by day – And by night: will ye not understand?
  • Shakir: And most surely you pass by them in the morning, – And at night; do you not then understand?
  • Muhammad Sarwar: You pass by (their ruined town) in the morning and at night. – Will you then not understand?
  • Mohsin Khan: Verily, you pass by them in the morning. – And at night; will you not then reflect?
  • Arberry: and you pass by them in the morning – and in the night; will you not understand?

The location that this verse is talking about is Sodom and Gomorrah because the preceding verses were talking about how Allah had destroyed the people of Lot.


I was made aware of this because of Ibn Warraq and Tom Holland who have written about Islam’s origins in gerat depth. Do read their work along with watching some of their videos on youtube.

Advertisements

How Old Was Aisha? [Sources]

Aisha was married at the age of 6 and the marriage was consummated when she was 9.

Sahih Bukhari reference

  • Volume 5, Book 58, Hadith 234
  • Volume 5, book 58, Hadith 236
  • Volume 7, Book 62, Hadith 64
  • Volume 7, Book 62, Hadith 65
  • Volume 7, Book 62, Hadith 88
  • Volume 7, Book 62, Hadith 90
  • Volume 8, Book 72, Hadith 151
  • Volume 9, Book 87, Hadith 140

Sahih Muslim reference

  • Book 8, Hadith 3309
  • Book 8, Hadith 3310
  • Book 8, Hadith 3311

Sunan Abu Dawud reference

  • Book 41, Hadith 4915
  • Book 41, Hadith 4916
  • Book 41, Hadith 4917

Sunan Nasai reference

  • Book 4, Hadith 3257
  • Book 4, Hadith 3258
  • Book 4, Hadith 3259
  • Book 4, Hadith 3260
  • Book 4, Hadith 3380
  • Book 4, Hadith 3381

Sunan Tirmihdi reference

  • Book 2, Hadith 1109

How can any one escape the conclusion that Muhammad was a pedophile.

Section U3.8

U3.8 (N:) As for Allah’s creating acts, we believe that the real doer or everything is Allah. He is the one who burns, not the fire or the person who lighted the fire; He is the one who cuts, not the knife or the person holding the knife; He is the one who drowns a man, not the water or the person who threw him in, and so forth. Here, people always raise the question that if Allah Most High is the real doer, why are people held responsible? The answer is that Allah Most High does not hold people responsible for creating the act, but rather for choosing the act. One proof of this is that a person who cannot choose is not held responsible, such as someone asleep, insane, a child, forced, unremembering, or someone who makes an honest mistake. The legal responsibility of such people is lifted because they lack full voluntary choice. Another proof is that Nimrod sinned for choosing to burn Ibrahim (upon whom be peace) even though Ibrahim did not burn (koran 21:69); and that Ibrahim (Upon whom be peace) became the Friend of the All-merciful for choosing to sacrifice his son out of obedience to Allah,even though his knife did not cut and his son was not sacrificed (Koran 37:105), all of this showing that the servant is held  responsible for his choice, which scholars of the divine unity (tawhid) term the servant’s acquisition (kasb).
As for Allah’s eternally preexistent knowledge, we believe that Allah knows everything before, during, and after it is, and knows how it is when it occurs. But does the servant have acess to this knowledge? Not at all. So the servant chooses to do acts on the basis of a desire within himself, not because he knows Allah’s knowledge, and he is held responsible for his choice even though it corresponds with Allah’s eternally preexistent knowledge.
It is clear from the above that belief in destiny means that Muslims believe Allah has destined and ordained matters in past eternity, and that nothing in existence lies outside of His eternal will, and He is the Creator of everything, while the servant is only held responsible for his own choice (Mudhakkirai fi al-tawhid (y113), 41-12). [Relliance of the Traveller, U3.8, pg613-4]

First humans are only tools in the hand of Allah ie when we light a fire it is Allah who has lighted it and burned the wood. Second everything is predestined which reinforces the first point.

This is the kind of belief that destroys a nation for eternity. I can criticize Islam as much as I can but Muslim scholars are the biggest liability to Islam.

Deen e Hanif

Why I chose Deen e Hanif as my title, has to do with the fact that Hanif, just like the word Hoor in Koran has been a mistranslation. Hanif actually meant heathen (while Hoor means white raisins, good luck dead suicide terrorists)

For centuries the religious people had unparalleled power rivaled only by the state and there were endless wars, absolute poverty, slavery, child-brides, genital mutilation, famine disease, blood sacrifice on and on. each time the religion claimed absolute knowledge of everything, economics, morality, biology, cosmology mixed with astrology, alchemy etc. However nothing the religious ever claimed worked as per the religious peoples claim, i.e. if you are ill then the deity is mad and the deity is cleaning you and if you don’t get healed then you need to atone for your sins and if it is not working then you were not sincere and do it all over again. every battle started with the prayers to the deity and often times both sides prayed to the same deity with one side winning and the other side losing. Why did one side win and not the other side?

Religious contribution towards the well being of the humanity and the environment (that doesn’t get mentioned enough) is nil. Religious people have constantly resisted change, supporting slavery till it finally died (although the jihadis have resurrected this evil practice again). Religious people give others only misery in the form of endless misery, emotional trauma rooted in fearing a non-existent deity and an endless logical fallacies such as if the deity is all powerful why is there poverty, injustice, human birth defects, anarchy in the whole universe etc.

Religious people have lied over and over again and every time the religious people have been caught with their pants down, they deny the error and change the whole meaning of the text and do large number of apologies that would not be sufficient if presented for criminal in the court of law. Religious people claimed victory when some passages in their text agreed with science but when other passages disagreed they went to the end of the earth to try to discredit the truth i.e. evolution.

Why do religious lie and never admit to the truth? Why are the religious people hypocritical?

There are many reason but I would present a few as to why the religious people say they are for the truth and then follow a lie. Religious people have lived in the position of power so long that they can’t let go of all the power, the free money, tax-breaks, at the cost of those who are intellectually dumbed down by the state working with the  religious figures. To the religious figures it doesn’t matter that they are causing couples to have a miserable life, always relating to the holy text instead of working out the problems by themselves.

Religious people have stopped their disciples from learning the truth, that is beautiful and sweet. All religious people have done is destroy their disciples lives and personality over trivial matters.

Religions and religious people have killed each other and will continue to kill each other.

It’s time people accept the cold hard facts that religion is a wish full thinking and a fantasy that will forever torment you and instead its time we all accept personal responsibility. Live a life we want and work towards making ourselves better and enjoy the little and happiness that comes our way and face the other side as well.